Wildlife Conservation Science & Policy

Dedicated to the social and political aspects–the so-called "human dimensions"–of wildlife management

How does experience with wolves affect media coverage?

We used the dataset on news media coverage about wolves to explore the question of how a society’s experience with wolves affects news media coverage.  After classifying nearly 30,000  statements about wolves as either positive or negative, we grouped all of the statements we coded into one of three categories: (1) states and provinces with permanent wolf populations, (2) states with “new” wolf populations (i.e., populations established since the passage of the ESA either via reintroduction or recolonization), and (3) states and provinces without wolves.

The first figure (below) shows the trend in news coverage (specifically, negative expressions per article) over time in these three groups.  Results show no significant trend in negative expressions per article among states and provinces with permanent population nor among states and provinces without wolves.  States with new wolf populations, on the other hand, demonstrated a significant increase in negative expressions per article.  Moreover, states with new populations exhibited more negative expressions per article (second figure).  These results suggest the increase in negative news media coverage over time is being driven primarily by states with new wolf populations.

Explanations

In our original analysis, we hypothesized that states with new wolf populations would have more negative news media coverage due to the novelty associated with the return of this species and a heightened perception of risk on the part of the population.  However, an alternate explanation exists for these data.  All of the states and provinces with permanent wolf populations also have reduced protections for wolves (the only state with a permanent population that is protected under the ESA is Minnesota, and wolves there are listed as threatened).  Another explanation for our findings is that the negative press is related to the degree of control that states/citizens have over wolf populations; specifically, as control decreases under the ESA, perception of risk increases leading to more negative attitudes and media coverage.  A final explanation deals with differing cultures; anti-government sentiment in the Rocky Mountain West make wolves a perfect surrogate issue for those seeking to promote anti-federalism and states’ rights issues.  Unfortunately, they data we’ve collected thus far don’t allow us to explicitly address these issues.

Advertisements

3 responses to “How does experience with wolves affect media coverage?

  1. Pingback: Are attitudes toward wolves in the US changing? « Wildlife Conservation Policy

  2. Cherylynn Costner December 7, 2010 at 10:25 pm

    Much of the most important wolf information has been recently discovered and is unknown to the general public at this time. Wolves can be hard to live around for many people even though the Native Americans lived with them for thousands of years and never hunted them and co-existed very well with them. However, the Europian culture has found or invented many deplorable attributes of the mythified wolf and that can be changed with education.

    A great movie to better understand why we need to learn to live with wolves and how they better wildlife in general is found at http://www.lordsofnature.org

  3. Phil December 17, 2010 at 10:16 pm

    Cherylynn: Being a senior in college pursuing a Biology in Animal Behavior degree, I enjoy all typs of wildlife, especially predator/carnivore ones. I am a strong believer in the importance and keystone role they play in ecosystems. One misconception people who disregard Wolves have is that they do not always eat their entire kill, but what they don’t realize is that Wolves cannot consume ALL of the carcass in one setting, and will come back to the carcass in different settings to eventually finish the carcass. This video shows this in a perfect example from the end of the clip. I will purchase this on dvd. Thanks for the link.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: